Author: Capricorn86 – written for brassband777`s birthday
Prompt: Sam has to spank both his teenaged daughters for something.
Characters: Sam Wincester, Emily (15) Alice (13)
Notes: Emily and Alice are Sam`s daughters, my Ocs in a AU verse where Dean and Sam live normal lives after leaving the hunting lifestyle.
Word count: 4,412
"It could have been worse," Dean stated simply once his brother had finished relating the days events to him.
Sam raised his eyebrows in disbelief, forgetting for a moment that he was on the phone with Dean and so the other man couldn`t see his expression.
"I get that you were mad, and you had every right to be," Dean went on. "But it could have been worse. What if they had taken the train to the next town for example? Alice doesn`t have a mobile yet, what if they had gotten separated, then what?"
Sam shuddered at the thought. "I`d like to think they would never do anything so reckless."
"Hm, well they`re still early in their teens, anything could happen," Dean retorted drily. "I`m just trying to put things into perspective for you. We pulled way worse stunts when we were about that age."
"Speak for yourself," Sam snorted.
"Flagstaff ring a bell?"
Sam clenched his jaw. That was below the belt. "Cheap shot," he muttered.
"It`s eleven thirty, what are you doing up?" Dean asked suddenly.
"Uhm, I`m an adult and get to pick my own bedtime?"
"Get your ass upstairs now! I had better not find you by the computer again when I come up!"
Sam realized Dean had been talking to one of his kids, and not him. "Dean?"
"Yeah, Sammy, sorry. Will is a bit of a computer addict, and it`s messing up his sleeping pattern. So on a scale of 1 to 10, how mad were you? I mean, what the girls did is a pretty big no-no in your book! I hope you didn`t kill them, I`m quite fond of my nieces you know!"
Sam rolled his eyes. Dean was always so dramatic. "No, Dean, I didn`t kill them, they`re both sleeping safely as we speak. But yeah, getting that call from the school didn`t exactly brighten my day..."
The two teenage girls sitting on the sofa were squirming under the stern, scrutinizing gaze of their father. Thirteen-year-old Alice didn`t even dare look up, she just sat there in silence, her fingers nervously twirling a lock of her blonde hair.
Her older sister Emily was not feeling very brave at the moment either. Both girls knew they had landed themselves in deep trouble with their father. Their great plan had worked perfectly until the school had called Sam to enquire about the absence of both his daughters. The headmaster had not been notified that both Winchester girls would be missing a day, and found it odd that Mr. Winchester had not called this morning to give notice. Sam himself had been completly unaware that neither of his daughters had attended school that day, and as he was standing before them now he was most eager to hear an explanation – and it had better be a good one!
Not that any reason the girls had for skipping school would save them from punishment. Sam knew that he would be delivering two spankings shortly, and he was not pleased about it.
"I`m still waiting to hear why the pair of you weren`t in school today," Sam growled. "Where were you all day? Who were you with? What were you doing?" A couple of seconds passed with neither of the girls speaking up, so Sam turned to his eldest. "Emily? Would you care to explain?"
The fifteen-year-old shifted uncomfortably in her seat. She knew she and her sister was busted, and the best thing to do right now was to tell the truth, and the whole truth. Outright lying or holding anything back would only make things worse for both of them. She cleared her throat. "Uhm... well.. Okay, you know Jason Sieger? He`s having that concert in Kansas City this weekend, the one you wouldn`t let us go to.."
Sam nodded, crossing his arms. He knew very well who Jason Sieger was, both his daughters were obsessed with him. Their rooms had several posters of the Canadian pop star, and whenever he permitted them to use his laptop, they`d go on YouTube and Spotify to view his music videos and stream his songs. It wasn`t exactly Sam`s cup of tea where music was concerned, but it was innocent enough, so he had managed to grin and bear it.
What had been more difficult to bear was the intense nagging and pleading from the girls – they had both wanted very badly to go to the concert in Kansas City and see their star live on stage. Sam had been adamant that it was out of the question. Emily had tried reasoning with him, she understood that Alice was too young, but surely she could go, if Sam went with her?
But for all her begging and whining her father had firmly stood his ground. They were both too young to attend a large outdoor concert, and that was the end of it.
Emily continued: "I read online that Jason was going to be at the mall here in Lawrence today only, to sign autographs."
It was a publicity stunt to promote his newly released album. Jason Sieger was currently touring the country, and each week he was going to appear at a select mall in the same state as he was holding a concert.
Emily explained that she and Alice had agreed to skip an entire day of school for the benefit of going down to the mall and getting in line for autographs as early as possible.
Needless to say, this did not count as a good reason for skipping in Sam`s book.
"Your education is more important than some singer scribbling his name on a CD cover," Sam said cooly. "I am very disappointed in both of you. Not only did you break my trust and skip a whole day of classes, you also put your safety at risk. Your behaviour has been completly unacceptable!" He paused for a moment. "Girls, look at me."
The two teenagers both lifted their eyes to meet their fathers gaze. They both felt terrible for disappointing him, yet they also felt that skipping one day of school wasn`t the end of the world. Meeting Jason had totally been worth it to them.
"Do you realize the danger you put yourselves in by being in the mall today, in that huge crowd? Any number of things could have happened. You could have been trampled! There are young girls like yourselves who have become seriously injured, even died, at events like concerts and autograph signings by stars at the mall due to pressure from the crowd and panic ensuing."
At this point, Emily felt the need to speak up in defense of herself and her sister. "It wasn`t that serious, Dad. I mean, sure, there were lots of people and stuff, but.."
"We just wanted to meet Jason," Alice put in, her voice barely audible.
"Yeah, and it`s not like we hopped on a train to go to the concert in Kansas City," Emily put in.
"Trust me, if you had gone to that concert, you`d both be grounded until you turned eighteen!" Sam snapped sharply. "And I don`t want to hear of either of you skipping school again, do I make myself clear?"
"Yes, Dad," Emily said respectfully, while Alice simply nodded.
"Alice Marie?" Sam prompted sternly.
"Yes, Daddy. I won`t skip school again."
"I`ll be contacting your teachers to have them email me any missed homework from today."
Emily resisted a strong urge to roll her eyes. Like they`d fall behind after missing one day! But she was wise enough not to comment on this, she knew how serious her father was about schoolwork.
"You`re both grounded for two weeks," Sam went on. "I want you straight home from school every day. There will be no friends over, including your cousins, and your tv, computer and phone priviliges are all suspended until further notice. You`ll also get extra chores."
The girls hearts sank. Their father sure was laying it on thick! They both hated being grounded, and not being allowed to see or talk to their friends outside of school was the worst. Their cousins went to different schools, which meant that with not being able to communicate with them online or on the phone, they`d be effectivly cut off from them for the next fortnight. This totally sucked! In the girls eyes, Sam was being quite unreasonable.
But the worst was yet to come.
"And finally, you`re both getting a spanking," Sam concluded, feeling the girls should have known this was coming. Still, he tried to ignore the surprised and scared looks on their faces. Spankings had become fewer and farther between for the girls after they had each turned twelve. Sam had gradually moved away from it as they hit the pre-teen stage, favouring other methods of punishment. His daughters had however never been under the impression that spankings were in the past. They knew that they found find themselves across Sam`s knee if he felt they had earned it.
In his mind, a proper over-the-knee spanking was required in this situation to ensure their behaviour was not repeated.
"Now I want both of you to go to your rooms, and I`ll be in to talk to you in a few minutes."
The girls wasted no time in obeying, but they certainly wished the "talk" could be avoided!
After sending the girls to their bedrooms, Sam went into his own to change his clothes. He was still in his "work-wear," and it always felt good to get out of the suit and tie at the end of a long day. He deliberatly hurried, not wanting to leave Alice waiting long. To any extent possible, he did his best to not make his children wait for a spanking, knowing from plenty of personal experience how agonizing it was. Sam also had to deal with his eldest, but he`d take care of Alice first, due to her being the youngest and by far the more sensitive of the two.
Once he was in jeans and a flannel shirt he headed across the hall and opened Alice`s bedroom door. Normally he knocked once before entering either of the girls rooms, but as he was coming to administer punishment, he chose to forego that sign of respect.
The petite thirteen-year-old was sitting on the edge of her bed, wringing her hands as she glanced up to see her father in the doorway. "Daddy, can`t you please change your mind about the spanking? I`m already grounded, which sucks bigtime, and I`ll never skip school again! I promise!"
"I`ll hold you to that promise," Sam said grimly, moving over to the bed and seating himself. "As for the spanking, it`s happening, so let`s get it over with." He grabbed Alice`s arm and quickly pulled her across his lap. As it was summer and quite warm wheather, the girl was wearing a skirt which Sam simply lifted before commencing to lay down fast, hard spanks over her pink hipster.
"Oww!" Alice immediatly went rigid as the first swat landed, and she continued to utter small exclaims of pain as the smacks kept coming.
After giving her about two dozen spanks, Sam paused. "Alice, I want you to really think about why you`re getting this spanking. Skipping school is bad enough, but you also put yourself in danger today by being part of what I`m sure was a big crowd at the mall. I know Emily was there to look after you, but what if you had gotten separated from her? You don`t have a mobile, so she couldn`t have reached you."
Alice sniffed, feeling tears burning in her eyes as she listened to her father`s words. Now that he had halted smacking her bottom, she felt even more how badly it was stinging! She wanted to retort that if Daddy had only gotten her a mobile there wouldn`t have been a problem, but things would get worse for her backside if she dared that, so she simply stated that she was sorry. And she really was!
Sam didn`t answer her. Instead he proceeded to pull down her underwear to get on with the spanking and really make the lesson stick.
Alice tried to cover her now naked bottom with her hand, but Sam ignored the silent plea. The young teen quickly started to cry as her father`s large handprint covered her rear end all over. As soon as the girl was reduced to tears, Sam added another round of smacks to her sit-spots before stopping completly.
Hearing Alice cry made Sam`s heart ache, but he knew the spanking had been called for. He gently rubbed her back for a couple of minutes, until her crying had quieted slightly, then helped her to stand.
The young teen fiercly rubbed her aching behind to reduce the sting, then put her underwear and skirt back in place, trying to ignore the throbbing pain as the skin came in contact with the fabric of her clothes.
Sam got up too, and hugged his subdued daughter tightly, running his hand across her blonde locks until her crying had completly halted. "It`s okay, baby girl. I`m not angry with you anymore."
He then broke the embrace and looked her in the eyes. "I love you very much. Remember that."
"I know, Daddy. I love you too." Alice was silent for a moment. "When I`m not grounded anymore, I can still go to the mall, right?"
"Yes, but remember our deal."
Alice had become worried that as her misbehaviour today had involved going to the mall, her hard-earned privilige of going there without parental supervision might be revoked. She was relieved to learn this was not the case.
She had felt quite unfairly treated when she had turned twelve and was still not allowed to go to the mall unless Sam or Uncle Dean was with her. Emily had been allowed to go there with her friends when she was twelve, so Alice had a hard time understanding why it was different for her.
The fact was that Sam had not considered his youngest daughter to be mature or responsible enough until she had turned thirteen. For the past few months, she had finally been allowed to go to the mall, but only together with a friend who had a mobile phone, so she could reach her father. Alice had also been told in no uncertain terms that if she broke the deal by not showing up at the regular meeting place for Sam to pick her up (without calling him to explain her delay) she would have to work hard to earn this privilige of trust back.
The issue of a mobile phone had also been the subject of some discussion. Sam would not be swayed on the point that neither of the girls would get mobiles until they each turned fourteen. Now Emily had had a phone for over a year, while Alice still had to wait until her next birthday to get hers. Life was so unfair!
"I have to go talk to your sister. Stay in your room until I come get you," Sam instructed.
Alice nodded, and after giving her a kiss on the cheek Sam left her bedroom.
While Sam had been talking with her sister, Emily had been lying on her bed, waiting and dreading the spanking she knew was coming. She had the signed CD cover lying on her nightstand, and she stroked it lightly with one finger as she reflected upon the days events.
Just a couple of hours earlier she had been ecstatic to meet her idol, the long wait at the mall had been totally worth it to see Jason Sieger in person.
Emily felt a prick of guilty conscience for the sake of her sister. It had been Emily who had discovered that Jason was signing autographs, but when she had told Alice that she intended skipping school to go meet him, her sister had insisted on coming along, despite Emily offering to get an autograph for her too. That way, Alice wouldn`t get in trouble if Emily got caught. Sam`s eldest had felt pretty confident in her plan however, and she realized that she couldn`t stop Alice from coming with her.
During the long wait before Jason had even arrived, Emily had been very glad that she wasn`t alone, and it had been wonderful sharing her excitement with her sister when the star showed up at last. They had both acted as wildly excited as only young teenage girls can get, screaming at the top of their lunges and jumping up and down to get a better view of the pop idol.
During Sam`s talk with the girls in the living room, Emily had tried defending them by stating that their safety hadn`t really been at risk as the crowd wasn`t that massive. The truth was that there had been a large gathering of teenaged girls at the shopping centre, and as the Winchester girls had arrived fairly early, they were standing in front and could really feel the intense pressure from the crowd. Nothing had happened, though. Emily felt certain that her father was exaggerating when he said that people had become injured at these kinds of events. As far as she had noticed, no girls had fainted or anything. Dad was just being over-protective. If he had his way, Emily and her sister would never get to do anything fun!
The fifteen-year-old sat up upon her father entering the room. She eyed him uneasily as he sat down on the bed next to her, not sure if he planned on putting her across his knee straight away of if she was in for a second lecture. She asked if there was any chance Sam would let her get away with just a grounding, to which he replied that as he had just spanked her sister, that would hardly be fair. "And besides," he added, "I`m pretty sure you were aware of the consequences of your actions if you got caught."
Emily looked down and nodded silently. She had hoped so badly to get away with it though! Still, she knew that her father was disappointed in her, which really hurt. She hadn`t meant to let him down, but meeting Jason Sieger had meant a great deal to both her and Alice. Seeing the look on her father`s face made her question whether it had been worth it.
"I hope you weren`t too hard on her," Emily said, referring to her little sister. "It was my idea, after all. I was going to go alone, and she just had to come along! She wouldn`t have gotten in trouble at all if-"
Sam interrupted her. "Well, did you force her? Did you put a rope around her waist and drag her with you?"
Despite herself, Emily had to smile at that. Even a little giggle escaped her at the comical mental images her vivid imagination created. "No, Dad, I didn`t make her do anything."
"There you go. Alice is responsible for her own actions and choices, just as you are for yours. You must both face the consequences when you make bad ones like you did today. Understand?"
Sam couldn`t even begin to count the times his older brother Dean had tried to take all the blame for something they had both had an equal part in. And every time John had given him a similar answer to what he`d just told his own daughter.
"And speaking of consequences..." Sam cleared his throat. "Stand up and drop your jeans."
With a small groan, Emily did as she was told. Once she had lowered her pants to her knees, Sam took her across his lap and immediatly started spanking her panty-clad bottom.
Emily jerked at the first swat, but managed to keep fairly silent as Sam got her warmed up. Soon the teen could really feel the sting and heat building in her rear end, and she started both wriggling and making her discomfort known.
Sam often reinforced his lecture while spanking, to make sure his daughter was well aware of why she was being punished. When the girls had been younger, he`d typically swat and speak at the same time, but now that they were getting older, he chose to pause in the spanking to make sure she was really paying attention to what he was saying. It also served a double purpose as Sam knew from his many trips across John Winchesters knee that once the spanking started up again it would hurt even more as you`d had time to really feel the sting. It had certainly helped John to get his point across, so Sam chose to take after his old man in this.
"Can you remind me why you are getting this spanking, Emily?"
"I skipped a whole day of school.."
"And I put myself in danger.. sort of.." The last part was barely audible, but Sam caught it. He chose to let it slide.
"And is that behaviour that I tolerate?" Sam asked next.
Emily wriggled over her fathers lap, tensing as she suspected her backside would be bared in a couple of seconds. "No."
"That`s right. I know you feel I`m too protective of you.."
"Understatement. OW, OUCH!" Emily yelled as Sam landed two extra hard swats to her butt. Sassing her dad while over his lap was a very bad idea!
Sam continued speaking: "But I am your father, and so I`ll always try to protect you and teach you how to protect yourself. Your safety, and that of your sister is the most important thing to me. So you can hate my rules all you want, but they`re in place for a very good reason. And if you break them, there will be consequences!"
In her current position, Emily was more worried about the safety of her backside to be very appreciative of her father`s concern.
Sam decided that it was time to move on with the punishment, and so he firmly tugged down Emily`s panties and swiftly set about turning her bottom a cherry red. Soon she was crying and apologizing, hoping for every smack to be the last.
Despite his daughters not being little girls anymore, having to spank them and listen to them cry was every bit as painful for Sam as it had been when they were younger.
He soon felt that he had gotten through to Emily, and like he had done with Alice, Sam rubbed her back to soothe her as she lay limp and sobbing over his lap. After calming down, the girl got up and fixed her clothes, feeling emberrassed at her nakedness.
Sam stood and held the tall fifteen-year old close to him for as long as she needed it. After a little while she took the initiative to pull away, and Sam looked down into her beautiful green eyes, seeing so much of himself and his own youth reflected back at him.
Sam let the girls stay in their bedrooms for a while to recover properly from the spankings they had recieved and to let his lecture sink in. Once she had gotten the green light from Sam, Emily moved into her sister`s room to check up on her. She found the younger teen lying on her stomach on the bed.
"My butt still hurts," Alice complained.
"You think mine doesn`t?" Emily retorted. "Join the club!" And the girls had to giggle, despite there not being anything remotely amusing about being spanked by their father.
"I still can`t believe we met Jason Sieger!" she went on, her gaze drifting to one of the large posters of him Alice had on her bedroom wall.
In Emily`s bedroom, Sam had hung a framed copy of a drawing his eldest had made of the star. She had sent the original work in to a teen magazine who was holding a contest, and her drawing had won the top prize of 100 $. Sam had been so proud he had boasted about it to both Dean and his co-workers. Emily had inherited every bit of her mothers creative and artistic talent, and it made Sam`s heart soar to see her put her abilities to good use.
"I know, right?" Alice got up from the bed. "He`s even cuter in real life!"
"Totally," her sister agreed.
"Emmy, can we make a deal? The next time Jason Sieger is signing autographs at the mall..."
"Say no more. We`ll get Dad to go down there!"
As if on cue, Sam appeared in the open doorway. "Dinner is just about ready. You girls hungry?"
"Oh my god, totally starving!" Alice exclaimed.
"Me too," Emily said. "Alice said she really wanted to do the washing up," she added mischeviously.
"No, I didn`t!" the thirteen-year-old objected hotly.
"Well, seeing as you`re both grounded, you can both set the table and wash up afterwards," Sam decided. "How does that sound?"
"Boring," Emily moaned. She hated doing housework, extra chores while being grounded really sucked.
"Yeah," Alice nodded, sharing her sisters feelings.
"I think you two are in for a whole lot of boring for the next two weeks," Sam said, not feeling the slightest bit sympathetic.
Sam looked at his eldest. "Yeah?"
"Uhm.. I.. I`m sorry.."
"I know you are, it`s ok."
"No, I mean, you`re way too protective of us, but..." Emily was trying to give her father a proper apology for her actions, but it was coming out rather awkwardly. It was difficult for the teenage girl to admit that her father had been right about the situation at the mall. She was trying to express that although she felt her dad should ease up on his rules, she also appreciated that he was concerned about her and her sister and wanted to keep them safe.
"You so totally are, Daddy," Alice chipped in.
"Well, it`s too bad you feel that way, cause that won`t ever change," Sam replied. "You`re my children, and it`s my job to keep you safe. I love you both so much."
"We love you too, Dad," Emily smiled and leaned into her fathers side. He wrapped one arm around her and Alice was happy to follow her sisters example. Sam stood with his arms around his girls and thanked his lucky stars that they were both safe and happy.